Discussion of 'Soil Water Retention Characteristics of Vertisols and Pedotransfer Functions Based on Nearest Neighbor andNeural Networks Approaches to Estimate AWC' by N. G. Patil, D. K. Pal, C. Mandal,and D. K. Mandal

摘要

Irrigation management in vertisols is one of the major challenges to increase agricultural productivity in India and many developing\udcountries. Unfortunately, information on hydraulic properties of these soils is very sparse. In an attempt to understand these soils for\udbetter management, 10 different functions were evaluated for their efficacy to describe soil-water retention characteristics (SWRC) of vertisols\udof India, and point pedotransfer functions (PTFs) were developed by using a nearest neighbor (k-NN) algorithm as an alternative to\udwidely used artificial neural networks (ANN) for prediction of available water capacity (AWC). Soil profile information of 26 representative\udsites comprising 157 soil samples was used for analysis. The Campbell model fit to measured SWRC data better than any other model, with\udrelatively lower root mean square error (RMSE) (0.0199), higher degree of agreement (0.9867), and lower absolute error on an average\ud(0.0134). Three other functions, namely, modified Cass-Hutson, Brooks-Corey, and Van Genuchten, also described the SWRC data with\udacceptable accuracy. Four levels of input information were used for point pedotransfer function (PTF) development: (1) textural data [data on\udsand, silt, and clay fraction (SSC)]; (2) Level 1 þ bulk density data (SSCBD); (3) Level 2 þ organic matter (SSCBDOM); and (4) Level 1 þ\udorganic matter (SSCOM). The RMSE in predictions by k-NN PTFs ranged from 0.0339 to 0:0450 m3 m3 with an average of\ud0:0403 m3 m3. The ANN PTFs performed with average RMSE 0:0426 m3 m3 and a range of 0.0395 to 0:0474 m3 m3. The k-NN algorithm\udprovided a viable alternative to neural regression with marginally better performance and the benefit of flexibility in the appending\udreference database. The results are significant because SWRC data are still in the development stage in India, and k-NN PTFs would have a\udgreater value because of the flexibility.